PAST WORK
Differential Rates
of Evolution
Aside from varying
in size, the protein-coding genes in the mt genome vary
in their rates of molecular evolution. Among the four
genes that meet the 900bp size threshold, COI and cyt
b evolve much more slowly than ND4 or ND5. This rate
variation has one important practical implication- it
is impossible to design universal primers for ND4 and
ND5, effectively ruling out their use as the basis for
a comprehensive DNA-identification system. By contrast,
because the other two genes evolve more slowly, it has
been possible to design primers for them with broad
taxonomic utility.
Aside from determining the ease
with which the DNA needed for sequencing can be recovered,
rates of molecular evolution influence the information
content of the resultant sequences. Obviously a gene
that showed no sequence changes across life would be
useless in a taxonomic context. Conversely a gene with
extremely high rates of evolution might distinguish
closely allied taxa, but could fail to discriminate
more distantly related forms because of secondary convergences.
In the case of protein-coding genes, information content
can be obtained by inspection of both nucleotide sequences
and amino acid arrays in the gene products. Because
amino acid composition is so conserved, analyses at
this level are most useful for identifying higher taxonomic
categories (phyla, classes, orders), while studies at
the nucleotide level are useful in making species-level
identifications.
COI
Versus Cyt b
Based on their large sizes and slow rates of molecular
evolution, COI and cyt b are the MT genes best suited
to serve as the basis for a DNA- identification system.
COI does have two important advantages over cyt b, both
linked to its slower rate of molecular evolution. Firstly,
the universal primers for this gene are very robust,
enabling the recovery of its 5' end from most animal
species. Furthermore, COI has a greater taxonomic signal
range than cyt b. Both genes do show a high incidence
of base substitutions at third position nucleotides,
allowing the discrimination of closely allied species.
However, COI provides better resolution of deeper taxonomic
affinities because its amino acid sequence changes more
slowly than that of cyt b. |